Skip to content
Mock Clinic
← Back to home

Sample marking report

Chest X-ray results

Illustrative example

PLAB 2 · General practice · Lorraine Pike, 61

This is the full report you get after every station, filled in with fictional feedback. Open each examiner checklist to see the evidence behind every criterion.

Overall 70 out of 100
Good✓ Critical action met

Good overall, with an average of 70/100 across the three domains. Interpersonal skills was your strongest area at 83%, and clinical management skills is the one to work on next at 63%. You completed the critical action.

Confident and well rounded. This is the standard to aim for.

These percentages and performance bands are Mock Clinic practice ratings, not official GMC marks or a prediction of your exam result. Start with the critical action, then practise one suggestion from “Next time”.

Scores are calculated from the assessed checklist using defined rules, with a separate critical-action check. Scoring version: plab2-checklist-v1. Compare progress with reports using the same scoring version.

Domain scores

Data gathering, technical and assessment skills

63%

Clinical management skills

63%

Interpersonal skills

83%

  • Unsatisfactory (0–39)
  • Borderline (40–54)
  • Satisfactory (55–69)
  • Good (70–100)

Data gathering, technical and assessment skills

63% · Satisfactory

5/8 checklist points

What you did well

  • You checked what Lorraine already knew before explaining anything (0:25): ‘What have you been told about the X-ray so far?’ This let you pitch the news at her level.
  • You asked how much detail she wanted, so she stayed in control of a frightening conversation.
  • You explored her six-week cough, tiredness and weight loss, and established that she was still working and managing normally.
  • You took a smoking history without blame and listened when she described her brother's illness.

What was missing

  • You didn't ask about blood in her sputum or chest pain. These red flags still matter when a referral is likely, because they change how quickly she needs to be seen.
  • You didn't find out who supports her. Her wife, Denise, was waiting in the car and could have joined the conversation.
  • You moved to the plan without summarising her history, so she had no chance to correct or add anything.

Next time

  • Cover the red flags in one line before the plan: ‘Have you coughed up any blood, or had any chest pain?’
  • Ask about support early: ‘Is there someone you'd like with you today, or someone at home we should think about?’
  • Summarise before moving on: ‘So that's six weeks of cough, some weight loss and more tiredness. Have I got that right?’
Examiner checklist · 2 met, 1 partly, 1 missed
  • MetChecks what she understands and how much she wants to know.‘What have you been told about the X-ray so far?’ followed by permission to explain.
  • PartlyAsks about cough, blood in sputum, weight loss, breathlessness and pain.Cough, weight loss and breathlessness explored; no question about pain or blood in sputum.
  • MetTakes a smoking and family history without blame.You asked about smoking and listened to her experience of her brother's illness.
  • MissedFinds out her support and who she wants involved.No discussion of support or involving her wife.

Clinical management skills

63% · Satisfactory

5/8 checklist points

What you did well

  • You explained the result honestly without overstating it (3:10): ‘This needs checking urgently, but the X-ray alone can't tell us for certain.’
  • You arranged an urgent suspected cancer referral and explained that a CT scan would be the next step.
  • You told Lorraine who would contact her and what would happen next, which was exactly what she wanted to know.
  • You agreed a follow-up call so she wasn't left waiting without support.

What was missing

  • You didn't offer support to stop smoking. Offered gently, after her immediate concerns, it shows you're looking after her whole health.
  • Your safety-net could have been more specific. Naming symptoms such as coughing up blood or worsening breathlessness makes it easier for her to act.
  • You didn't say what to do if the appointment doesn't arrive, which leaves a gap in an urgent pathway.

Next time

  • Once she has taken in the news, ask permission: ‘Would it be all right to talk about support with smoking? There's help whenever you're ready.’
  • Make the safety-net concrete: ‘If you cough up blood, become more breathless or feel much worse, please call us the same day.’
  • Close the loop on the referral: ‘If you haven't heard about the appointment within a week, ring us and we'll chase it.’
Examiner checklist · 3 met, 1 partly, 1 missed
  • MetExplains the X-ray is suspicious but does not confirm cancer.‘This needs checking urgently, but the X-ray alone cannot tell us for certain.’
  • MetArranges an urgent suspected lung cancer referral and explains a CT scan will follow.You explained the urgent specialist referral and further imaging.
  • PartlyGives a clear follow-up and safety-net if she is not contacted or symptoms worsen.You agreed a follow-up call and explained how to seek help sooner.
  • MissedOffers smoking cessation support sensitively.No offer of support in this consultation.
  • MetCritical action: Communicates the suspicious finding honestly and makes an urgent suspected lung cancer referral with a concrete follow-up plan.The concern, urgent referral and follow-up plan were all communicated.

Interpersonal skills

83% · Good

5/6 checklist points

Examiner feedback statements

  • Does not use language the patient can understand, or check understanding

What you did well

  • You gave a warning shot before the result (2:40): ‘I'm afraid the X-ray has shown something we need to look into.’
  • When she asked ‘Is it cancer?’, you said honestly that it could be, without presenting it as confirmed.
  • You allowed silence after the news and let Lorraine speak first, rather than filling the pause.
  • You acknowledged her fear: ‘After what happened to your brother, I can understand why this feels frightening.’

What was missing

  • You didn't explore her worry about not meeting her grandchild, which was what mattered most to her.
  • You didn't check her understanding before ending, so you couldn't be sure the plan had landed.

Next time

  • Ask about her main worry directly: ‘What's going through your mind right now?’ Then respond to what she tells you.
  • Close with: ‘Just so I know I've explained it clearly, could you tell me what happens next?’
  • Offer written information about the referral, so she has something to share with her family.
Examiner checklist · 2 met, 1 partly, 0 missed
  • MetGives a warning shot, uses plain language and allows silence.You prepared her for a concerning result, avoided jargon and paused.
  • MetAnswers ‘is it cancer?’ honestly, with appropriate uncertainty.You directly acknowledged the possibility without presenting it as confirmed.
  • PartlyResponds to her fear about her brother and grandchild with empathy.Her brother's illness was acknowledged; the worry about her grandchild was not explored.

Get a report like this on your own consultation.

Speak with an AI patient for eight minutes and your report is ready straight after. Then talk it through with your AI tutor.

Try a station free

No card needed.